The Dwindling Magic: How YA is Reshaping Contemporary Fantasy

I recently walked into a bookstore, an experience that always fills me with a mix of nostalgia and anticipation. The science fiction/fantasy section, always one of my favorite haunts, glimmered with bright, colorful covers. There were swords aplenty, dragons coiled in menacing poses, and heroines staring defiantly into a storm—or perhaps their own destiny. Yet as I combed through the shelves, my heart sank. It wasn’t just that I’d seen these tropes before (I had, many times); it was the overwhelming sameness of it all. I’d come looking for something akin to Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell by Susanna Clarke or the intricacy of Ursula K. Le Guin’s Earthsea. Instead, I found an ocean of YA pastels, all flashing similar neon signposts of first love, chosen ones, and simplistic world-building. The variety of narrative voices and literary ambition that had once defined the genre seemed absent.

This anecdotal encounter is not unique. It speaks to a larger trend in contemporary fantasy: the dominance of young adult (YA) fiction in shaping the market. While there’s no denying that YA fiction has inspired millions of young readers and brought a remarkable diversity of voices to the genre, its ascendancy has reshaped the field in ways that make it increasingly difficult for other kinds of fantasy to flourish. In focusing so heavily on YA, publishers, authors, and readers risk flattening a genre that has always thrived on its complexity and depth.

Let’s begin with a note of fairness: YA fantasy has done wonders for the publishing world. Series like J.K. Rowling’s Harry Potter, Suzanne Collins’ The Hunger Games, and Leigh Bardugo’s Shadow and Bone have brought fantasy into the mainstream like never before. They’ve cultivated a generation of readers who are now voracious consumers of books, many of whom might not have picked up a novel otherwise. The accessibility of YA fantasy—its fast-paced narratives, relatable characters, and themes of self-discovery—creates a perfect entry point for younger audiences. This is a good thing.

Moreover, YA fantasy has introduced much-needed diversity into the genre. Authors like Tomi Adeyemi (Children of Blood and Bone) and Rebecca Roanhorse (Trail of Lightning) have brought fresh perspectives that challenge the Eurocentric dominance of traditional fantasy. These are remarkable accomplishments that deserve celebration.

But therein lies the rub: the immense success of YA fantasy has come at a cost. Publishers, ever attuned to market trends, now heavily prioritize YA over other subgenres. The gravitational pull of YA’s commercial viability has transformed it into the de facto template for fantasy writing, leaving less room for experimental, ambitious, or literary works.

The consequences of this shift are subtle but significant. For one, the tropes and structures that work well in YA fantasy—straightforward world-building, coming-of-age arcs, and love triangles—often feel out of place in more complex narratives. These elements work wonderfully for younger readers because they simplify the complexities of the world into digestible, emotionally resonant stories. But when they dominate the landscape, they risk reducing fantasy to a predictable formula.

Consider the difference between a work like Patrick Rothfuss’s The Name of the Wind, which balances lush prose with a sophisticated, slow-burn narrative, and a typical YA fantasy novel. Rothfuss’s work demands patience; its emotional resonance grows not from a simple romance but from the aching intricacies of Kvothe’s life, where triumphs are hard-won and failures are devastating. Such nuance is rare in YA fantasy, where the need for immediate stakes and resolution often overrides deeper exploration.

Similarly, compare the literary ambition of Gene Wolfe’s The Book of the New Sun to many of today’s bestsellers. Wolfe’s work is dense, erudite, and layered with philosophical questions. It doesn’t spoon-feed its readers; it requires effort, a willingness to wrestle with ambiguity. Yet works like Wolfe’s are increasingly rare because they do not fit the mold of what the market believes fantasy should be: accessible, fast-paced, and aimed at a wide demographic.
​
This is not to say that all YA fantasy lacks depth or ambition. Writers like Laini Taylor (Strange the Dreamer) and Philip Pullman (His Dark Materials) prove that YA can achieve literary heights. However, their successes are the exceptions rather than the rule, and even their works often get marketed as “crossover” because they appeal to older readers as much as younger ones. The problem lies in the overwhelming prioritization of YA at the expense of everything else.

One of the great strengths of fantasy is its ability to grow with its readers. The joy of discovering Tolkien’s The Lord of the Rings as a teenager is only deepened when revisiting it as an adult, discovering new layers of meaning. Yet today’s market often encourages readers to stay within the confines of YA, cycling endlessly through variations on the same themes and archetypes.

This is where humility and wit come into play. As readers, we all have a tendency to stick with what feels comfortable. There’s nothing wrong with enjoying YA fantasy well into adulthood—good writing is good writing, no matter the target demographic. But if we want fantasy to thrive as a genre, we need to encourage readers to explore beyond those constraints. We need publishers to take risks on ambitious projects that defy easy categorization. We need writers to feel confident in crafting stories that challenge their readers instead of catering solely to their expectations.

Focusing on YA is not ruining contemporary fantasy in and of itself, but it is reshaping the genre in ways that risk its long-term vitality. The magic of fantasy lies in its ability to transport us to other worlds while reflecting on the complexities of our own. This magic thrives on diversity—not just in terms of representation but in narrative style, ambition, and scope.

Let’s celebrate what YA fantasy has achieved while also making space for works that demand more of us. Let’s encourage young readers to graduate to the richness of Clarke, Le Guin, and Wolfe. And let’s not be afraid to challenge the market’s love affair with accessibility, remembering that some of the best stories take time to find their audience. After all, the most enduring magic is often the most elusive.